There’s been some discussion on the Lochac Archers list about the thickness of Blunts and what the Tolerance on that thickness should be. So archers would like to be able to use 11/32nds of an inch shafts for their Combat Arrows, and others just want a definitive rulling made on that actual thickness and variances. There was also Discussion on Alternative means of ruling, however such a major change in the ruling would certainly greatly change surprize Arrow inspections.
One of my issues with arrow testing is that at 2 wars I have been to in the last year, Marshals have insisted on having every arrow inspected for width or length. Personally I think this is a little excessive. For arrows to be effective some consistance needs to be maintained… and an Archer making his or her own arrows won’t purposely make arrows out of spec, as they would be fully aware of the fact that they can be bounced at any point. An arrow that is out of spec, is likely to only just be out of spec, by a small amount, certainly not enough to make unsafe, as there should be a huge safety margin.
The idea of the rules is to provide a guide to constucting your arrows, not a means by which to ban them. When the rules say that you should use 5/16th’s or 8mm shafts should be used, that means that if you by those sized shafts then you have done the right thing… any variance in the shaft diameter should be within the manufacturers tolerance, however if one arrow falls out of that tolerance, should it be removed from the field? I don’t think so… I think it should be marked… I think it should be monitored more thoroughly than all the rest… And if complaints are made about it then it should be removed. If it’s proven that a batch of arrows are out of tolerance, then the batch should be removed and the maker of the arrows questioned as to what wood was purchased.
Why do I think that single arrows shouldn’t be removed? Because variances in weight and spine can be so high as to make a greater differance in the Ouch Factor and safety of the arrows. If an arrow is marked as a known issue, and people start noticing that that arrow is hitting harder, then sure, remove it. If the owner is smart, he’ll remove it himself. At about $3-$4 the cost of Combat arrows are too high to arbitrarily be bouncing arrows here there and everywhere just because they are slightly too thick or thin. Archers go through enough arrows each war through normal use than to have slightly out of tolerance arrows bounced through some Marshalls insistance that

Subscribe











